Signature Showoff Thread

**Rampage** · 12-26-2006, 08:07 AM

:[ PAMELA SKIPPED ME

btw its a manip

Originally Posted by SaReVoK

Mine v v

original

**Noobie_4_Lifey** · 12-26-2006, 09:39 AM

IMO. Looks like you just took a pciture, croped it and went all out smudging it in places. 3.5/10 No text or border. Just a smudged picture. (I am a noob so dont take my opinion to heart)

**Rampage** · 12-26-2006, 12:36 PM

Hmm obviously you havnt seen a movie border.... see those black bars on the top and bottom???? theres my border....and oh look theres the text on the hood of the car...hmm.... >.> and they arent smudges there emboss, ripple more emboss and spatter. theres also bluring sharpening...gradientmaps color overlay... and the manip is car explosions so...yeaa :)

and now...ima hve to say the same for you ...

1. no borders at all....(and you called me on this) -.-
2. look for some text tuts
3. no main point of focus on car sig

btw its a manip.

**Pamela** · 12-26-2006, 05:52 PM

Man I can.t do that stuff to save my life. I may not know *great* I just know what I like. Seeing as how I barely know how to post pics....well...nuff said.

**Mushroomhead18nc** · 12-26-2006, 07:47 PM

I guess I'll shoot mine up here. Keep in mind Frogman made it for me.

**Rampage** · 12-26-2006, 10:35 PM

honestly...i think ive seen better from froggy
7.5/10 :)

:[ damnnnn skipped again....

Originally Posted by SaReVoK

**SilverTears** · 12-26-2006, 11:22 PM

SK why do you keep reposting your signatures? Its already been rated... anyway it doesnt look like much anything. Its to dark, on the sides it looks like you just smudged a mess. The car isnt pictured in well and I cant remember how many times Ive said this but get a new text, every signature has that same ugly font in it with the same style, try getting text that fits in with the signature. 4/10

**xIntegrityx** · 12-27-2006, 10:42 AM

I just made this using Frogman's tut. I like it a lot, but I'd like to know how others feel about it. Thanks. =]

**Z3R0** · 12-27-2006, 01:07 PM

I like the border, and the image. The motion blur (I'm assuming it is a motion blur) isn't spread our enough. It looks like you just copied the render layer and put the copies behind the original but slightly off. Try blurring the motion effect some more and making it a little more spread out. Also, the positioning of the text is in a bad place and is difficult to read. The colors clash. Violet is correspondent with the red, but green does not fit well, it is not a complement of either color. Replacing the red with blue might work better. Color schemes play a very big role in any design. For a new artist, 5.5/10

**xIntegrityx** · 12-27-2006, 04:32 PM

I did copy the render layer multiple times. v.v And the red green and blue was for the tri-force theme. Forrest, fire, and water. But thank you for the honest review. =]

**Pamela** · 12-28-2006, 09:51 AM

Originally Posted by SaReVoK

:[ PAMELA SKIPPED ME

btw its a manip

original

Did Not! lol It is awsome!

**Noobie_4_Lifey** · 12-28-2006, 03:41 PM

Originally Posted by Divine

SK why do you keep reposting your signatures? Its already been rated... anyway it doesnt look like much anything. Its to dark, on the sides it looks like you just smudged a mess. The car isnt pictured in well and I cant remember how many times Ive said this but get a new text, every signature has that same ugly font in it with the same style, try getting text that fits in with the signature. 4/10

Thank you for stating what I got told off for. Saying it just looks like a whole lot of smudging.

**SilverTears** · 12-28-2006, 03:47 PM

To tell you the truth if he wants to be a **** about what people think about his work then why is he posting it up in the first place? This is the show-off thread. Meaning you post, and other people post their opinions on your work. If they dont like this, dont post a signature... simple as that. If they continue oh well tough titties.

**Noobie_4_Lifey** · 12-29-2006, 02:44 AM

I know. And I clearly wrote I am a noob not to take my opinion to heart. But it sounds o me like he took it to heart. anway back on topic.

**dim_sum** · 12-29-2006, 01:15 PM

Okie dokie, I've had phoshop for like 2 weeks so I'm really noob, so don't be too mean :) this is my first sig....would appreciate tips tho

**Halcyon** · 01-01-2007, 07:22 AM

It's ok, the render is too blurred in my opinion, it's fine if it is blurred on the outsides but make the focus point sharp. The text is ok, but the texture of the sig is just another render or two, which I'm not a huge fan of if it isn't an actual texture like wood or something like that. Not bad, but not amazing. 6/10

Tried out SK's movie borders, just brushing and coloring and some other things, it started out like a normal signature but i decided just to keep it as the brushing seemed to make a great picture in my mind of a church or building.

**Z3R0** · 01-01-2007, 10:27 AM

I like the brush work. It has a steady flow from the left to the bottom right corner. However, there isn't really that much color in it and it gives it a dulled effect. Also, the text it hard to read and is halfway in and out of your border, which doesn't really make it a border anymore. :P

IMO: 7/10

**dim_sum** · 01-01-2007, 04:12 PM

Originally Posted by zerokool

I like the brush work. It has a steady flow from the left to the bottom right corner. However, there isn't really that much color in it and it gives it a dulled effect. Also, the text it hard to read and is halfway in and out of your border, which doesn't really make it a border anymore. :P

IMO: 7/10

What do you mean by the text is out of the border? lol