Bigdeath vs [/sarcasm]

[[/sarcasm]]

Well, it has just been brought to my attention that I suck at making sigs... According to bigdeath. He took a shot at my ability and we did some conversing in PMs as we ought to, but he made some shots at my work such as "I wouldn't show it to a blind man without getting red in the face" and the like.

Well, now I decided to make it public. Which current do you guys think is better?

Mine:


or

His:


Critique as you see fit.

[FraterPerdurabo]

I prefer Sarcasm's.

By the way, since I know nothing about making sigs (judge from my own ) I just vote for the one that looks better to me, not for the one that has "more advanced editing" or something like that.

[The Orgasmatron]

I prefer Sarcasm. The picture looks better, the text looks better, the blending is better, and the whole creative design looks better.

Sarcasm wins this one in my opinion.

[Dan]

sarcasm yours looks cleaner, and better well done. goes to u all the way

[Mathalamus]

sarcasm is betterby 200% lol the design is very good blening is good
and the dowside it its not animated lol

sarcasm wins

[Bartender]

Bigdeath prefers the "Hell" theme, Sarcasm on the other hand, prefers the Earth-ish/Heaven-ish theme/colors, even though his is kind of basic looks better and cleaner.

[Halcyon]

Sarcasm ftw.

[Aemaeth]

Sarcasm.
Bigdeath's sigs look like dog turd.
What with the awfull animation and lack of border.

[Bloodangel26]

i voted for bigdeath but somehow bigdeath still has zero votes...

[Bartender]

Whoa Platinum is right, the ring around the hole in the ceiling looks like turd.

[Bloodangel26]

sarcasims is cleaner and more well done, but i think bigdeath's is cooler

[Halcyon]

Sarcasm, may I ask where you got that render?

[fleaflickerx]

big death all the way.

[chicken24]

Well.. I like both pretty good.. but i think i prefer Bigdeath's. Sarcasim's seems a little too mono-colored to me.

[commandwolf]

Sarcasm because bigdeath's looks a lil messy

[[/sarcasm]]

Sarcasm, may I ask where you got that render?

I actually got it in a render package of over 1000 renders. However, I was linked directly to a fileshare link and I have absolutely no idea if it is up now or not.

[Siris]

[/sarcasm] its blended and as a whole is cleaner though i dont prefer that particular color. but its not my sig so how cres right?

[FrogMan]

Well bigdeath you are getting better... but you not close to sarcasm yet, everything is sarcasms sig fits well together, his text is nice, border is good and its a good size sig... only thing is, that it is mono coloured but even that fits well with the sig.

You have made great improvement bigD but not enough yet.

[10 man]

big death . you already know i dont like yours. sorry and sarcasms is ok.. not super cool or anything.

[Irrelevant]

Sarcasm is the better designer.