Sig Of The Week # 1 vote thread

[FraterPerdurabo]

Didn't like the chicken at all. Boring colors and crappy picture.

I liked Dannation's because it was nice and "clear'. Did not have too much stuffed inside it, but then I saw Spiderman and changed my mind.

Didn't like Ghosts, too simple and I don't like the theme.

So it was down to Reeferman's and Ubergrossman's.

Reeferman, I really liked yours, but I just thought that you could have made a better job of it. Some extra work on contours and it would have got my vote.

Ubergrossman, I have no idea what your sig is about, but it really looks good. It does not have too many things stuffed inside it and the blending is good.

By the way, these are my humble opinions, and I know nothing about Photoshop/art, so you can me as an innocent bystander.

[SilverTears]

SBA - My vote goes to you. Pretty nicely done, at first I wasn't so sure about the greenish coloring, but I'm cool with it. Also, the text seems a bit fuzzy. In terms of the border, I guess it would depend on your forum bg or whatev (mine happens to be dark so white looks kinda odd, but whatever works for your forum color).
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dannation - Very nice text and the tealish thing at the bottom to go with it (best text of the bunch), except it seems a bit too empty for me (aka seems like a bit too much bg and render in the corner, although I can tell why it's there). Otherwise I would have voted for you.

Ghost - I'm not sure about the sig - I usually like to know what's in it, and the render (whatever kind of machine or beast it is that seems to have multiple hands and holding some kind of axe, sword, and shield; no idea) seems a bit too complicated for my tastes. The bg is nicely done; doesn't seem like it really goes with the render too well however.

UGM - Kinda like dustoid said and what I said about Ghost; my first assumptions were that it was some kind of ship and multiple ships, not exactly sure; also the text prolly could've gone better with the sig.

Chicken - Pretty nice brushing; just seems a bit too yellowish and prolly could've done a bit better on text.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
It was a pretty tough vote; gj all, and good job getting a SOTW running here.

Agreed

[10 man]

ok well the vote is over. sba wins i guess. so sba you can add get the mods to give you they "nice" pink text on your name now. thanks everyone for participating and i hope to see you all in this next one, sotw 2.

[XNightxRavenX]

Ima definitely have to go with ubergrossman..his is effin pimp...haha..but seriously they all good, but his is the best.