07-14-2006, 09:27 AM
But see hunter, the variable in the guys question that submitted this puzzle makes this impossible...why?
Because the lier can tell lies and truth...this puzzle is ment to be this..
Only one can tell ONLY LIES, and the other can tell ONLY Truth.
That way, my interpretation is correct. BUT, the way the guy said it is
The LIE AND TRUTH makes this impossible.
Why?
Because if you ask one guard something, it can be either or, there is no way telling who is who...because basicly saying the LIER is a LIER AND A TRUTH, there is no way to figure out how..
No matter what you ask them, even if you ask the lier two questions, you won't know..
You can ask the lier this...
Do you exist? He can say yes, THat's a TRUE answer, so you think thats him, but see, then you can ask him show me the door, and he can point to the hell door, and that is the point of this puzzle.
Either he rewords it and i win, or nobody will figure this out...
Because the lier can tell lies and truth...this puzzle is ment to be this..
Only one can tell ONLY LIES, and the other can tell ONLY Truth.
That way, my interpretation is correct. BUT, the way the guy said it is
Invisible Wrote:One can ONLY tell the TRUTH. and the other can LIE AND tell the TRUTH. you may only ask one question to both of the gaurds
The LIE AND TRUTH makes this impossible.
Why?
Because if you ask one guard something, it can be either or, there is no way telling who is who...because basicly saying the LIER is a LIER AND A TRUTH, there is no way to figure out how..
No matter what you ask them, even if you ask the lier two questions, you won't know..
You can ask the lier this...
Do you exist? He can say yes, THat's a TRUE answer, so you think thats him, but see, then you can ask him show me the door, and he can point to the hell door, and that is the point of this puzzle.
Either he rewords it and i win, or nobody will figure this out...