I noticed This About Exile

[xNemesis]

Everywhere I look for information on the Exile shield, I notice there are two types of them. I was wondering which one is better for smiter?

This one:

Exile Vortex Shield (45% Resists)

Defense: 1010-1136
Chance To Block: 44%
Durability: 44 of 44
[Paladin Only]
Required Strength: 138
Required Level: 66
+45% Resist All
15% Chance To Cast Level 5 Life Tap On Striking
Level 13-15 Defiance Aura When Equipped (varies)
+2 To Offensive Auras (Paladin Only)
+30% Faster Block Rate
Freezes Target
+220-260% Enhanced Defense (varies)
Replenish Life +7
+5% To Maximum Cold Resist
+5% To Maximum Fire Resist
25% Better Chance Of Getting Magic Items
Repairs 1 Durability in 4 Seconds
Ethereal

OR


Exile Vortex Shield (**% ED)
Defense: 924-1040
Chance To Block: 44%
Durability: 44 of 44
[Paladin Only]
Required Strength: 138
Required Level: 66
15% Chance To Cast Level 5 Life Tap On Striking
Level 13-15 Defiance Aura When Equipped (varies)
+2 To Offensive Auras (Paladin Only)
+30% Faster Block Rate
+-**% Enhanced Damage
+108 To Attack Rating
Freezes Target
+220-260% Enhanced Defense (varies)
Replenish Life +7
+5% To Maximum Cold Resist
+5% To Maximum Fire Resist
25% Better Chance Of Getting Magic Items
Repairs 1 Durability in 4 Seconds
Ethereal

I'm assuming its the one with the damage, but what makes them different, and which one is better for a smiter?

Thanks,
xNemesis

[Tap]

well personally i think the ed exile is better for a PvP smiter and the +res one is better for PvM. i could be wrong but this is what i think

[Inventor]

Resistance in my opinion

[Ares]

res is better for both i think

[xNemesis]

okay im planning on ubering with this char soo go with the resists?

[Ares]

yeah meph has a STRONG conviction you might have to use salvation to take him down ot just to life tap

[Stratocaster23m]

gotta go with resis

[L4E]

ed does not increase ur ****ing smite dmg.. how many times do i have to say this before u people understand?

and if u say the ed from fort or a pally shield is any different than any other type, thats just a stupid remark because the ed from a pally shield stacks with ed jewels or pheonix runeword and thus, does nothing to smite

[skidude]

okay im planning on ubering with this char soo go with the resists?

doin ubers u will need to resis exile

[Tap]

doin ubers u will need to resis exile

thats untrue ive always perferred ed exiles and my smiters are never in need of resists. and L4E you might be right, but considering i dont need res why not use the ed shield just incase it magically gives me more dmg.

[chdnny]

edit