Star Trek or Star Wars

[Mathalamus]

ya and his supspace distrorter.. i mean the force

well in my mind the glatic e,pire was weak and fell to the mathal Union within 8 yeaers.. the death star blew up a couple planets tho

[Metalhead Steve]

Your delusional man. Do you roleplay something because if you do, you do to much.

[darth_dub]

I like them both but starwars is alot better than startrek.

[Gods]

I like them both but starwars is alot better than startrek.

Agreed, this was a ahrd decision but Star Wars is the best I say.

EDIT: 500th post YAY!

[Mathalamus]

Your delusional man. Do you roleplay something because if you do, you do to much.

i just love RPG ok?

i still like star wars and mathal intelligence stole a couple of those big ships

[BewarethePhoenix]

I have to vote for Star Trek due to the "love story" we were all subjected to in more recent SW films. Really that was some of the dryest most forced dialog ever. Lucas can do a lot of things, love stories apparently not among them.

Oh yeah, and R2 units and lasers would get totally pwned by all of ST except maybe the wussies from Enterprise.

BTW How come there is no mention of Babylon 5 LOL

[SpoonMan999]

Search for the other Star Treak vs. Star Wars thread from a while back. By comparing the technical manuals just Boba Fett's ship, Slave 1, could destroy the entire federation fleet.

[Mathalamus]

well i know that but they can mobilize a large federation/klington (sorry no romulan) fleet and destry that ship

federation/klingon vicory at the costof hundreds of ships

[fleaflickerx]

mind you guys this is not a role playing thread, stay on topic

[Venom]

the fact is that the fed's needed help to take down a single personal figher thats just sad and if the sonic mines are included with the armaments of his ship then he cant be stoped

sonic mines FTW

[Mathalamus]

the fact is that the fed's needed help to take down a single personal figher thats just sad and if the sonic mines are included with the armaments of his ship then he cant be stoped

sonic mines FTW

as i recall the star wars ships are much much more powerful than anything the star trek as ( exept mabye for Q) for all we know it dosnt have an energy sheild.. board the ship and steal thier techology!

and the feds can take the ship out just fine.. they bitching klingons want a major victory agansit an uber ship.... and there allies

BTW the ships weapons arent infinite... theyy run out and be hammered by federation ships till they blow cause there phasers are infinite

[Venom]

as i recall the star wars ships are much much more powerful than anything the star trek as ( exept mabye for Q) for all we know it dosnt have an energy sheild.. board the ship and steal thier techology!

and the feds can take the ship out just fine.. they bitching klingons want a major victory agansit an uber ship.... and there allies

BTW the ships weapons arent infinite... theyy run out and be hammered by federation ships till they blow cause there phasers are infinite

1. every fighter has sheilds
2. you cannot board a ship that is specificly designed for a single pilot
3. by the time they run out of ammo your fleet have been destroyed by superior weaponry or a second squadren are replacing the first for rearmament

you still dont understand that your star trek is being owned by fighter craft and not the actual fleet of ships which easily out number the fed's

Q dont count since there beings that dont give a rats ass for you

stargate series are capable of raping the feds with naquda enhaced nukes,
pryer ships, ancient's weaponry,etc

[SpoonMan999]

Yeah, that was just referring to a single ship now imagine if the federation went up against the The Executor, supder star destryoed, or the Arc Hammer, can produce droid fighters.

[Mathalamus]

one: you CAN board the Ship, kill the pilot and pilot back to the nearest base
two everyone likes the feds so every single race will ally with the feds to defeat the invaders
three: nukes suck
four the arc hammer is a crappy thing easy pwn by a couple of quantum's.
five i dont think that the galatic republic has more than ten thousand ships... i think
oh and dont discount the borg, they have an uncountible numer of ships and the galatic republic can invade a quarter, mabye half before they get beaten back to where they came from
six: the federations a large sace, you need AT LEAST 2 million ships to keep the population under control
plus the dominion hates the galatic republic

[Venom]

oh have you ever seen a size comparison of star wars ships and star trek ships?
http://www.st-minutiae.com/misc/comparison.gif
look and cry
the super star destroyer is about 5x larger than a cube
and 2x larger than the voth city ship

now factor in that the super stardestroyer is built for war the ammount of weapons that can be placed on 17080 m ship, that have hangers built to hold stardestroyers

Star Wars vs Star Trek Essays: Star Wars vs Star Trek in Five Minutes
found the old link

[SpoonMan999]

one: you CAN board the Ship, kill the pilot and pilot back to the nearest base
two everyone likes the feds so every single race will ally with the feds to defeat the invaders
three: nukes suck
four the arc hammer is a crappy thing easy pwn by a couple of quantum's.
five i dont think that the galatic republic has more than ten thousand ships... i think
oh and dont discount the borg, they have an uncountible numer of ships and the galatic republic can invade a quarter, mabye half before they get beaten back to where they came from
six: the federations a large sace, you need AT LEAST 2 million ships to keep the population under control
plus the dominion hates the galatic republic

Dude, if one fighter can destroy a Federation ship in one shot do you think they need numbers on their side? And my point with the Arc Hammer is a ship with an unlimited supply of fighters. You can go ahead and try boarding the ship if you can make it to one.

[Mathalamus]

cloaking device and the element of surprise.. if you do it correctly you can do that without any losses ( very very difficult tho

@ venom.. damn i cant put anything more for defense.. although the Borg can stand up to it i guess with there thousands of ships

AND IT DEPENDS ON TECHNOLOGY!!!

i don't think they have transporters but in order to take over a super star destroyer you need... nearly present earth population of red shirts to even take over a super star destroyer

and one more thing (if you've seen emperors cloak from DS9 ships that fly insanely close often cant get shot but what do i know? a single ship rammed the thing and it blew up...i think

BTW i want the executor class ship... its cool and i need one to.... get the civilians in line.. bwahahahaha!!!

[fleaflickerx]

Ok, this is the last time I'm going to say this before I put the boot down,
Next post after this that talks any thing about one faction kicking anothers ass is going to get warned, I've said it once and have been completely ignored.

[Dan]

cloaking device and the element of surprise.. if you do it correctly you can do that without any losses ( very very difficult tho

@ venom.. damn i cant put anything more for defense.. although the Borg can stand up to it i guess with there thousands of ships

AND IT DEPENDS ON TECHNOLOGY!!!

i don't think they have transporters but in order to take over a super star destroyer you need... nearly present earth population of red shirts to even take over a super star destroyer

and one more thing (if you've seen emperors cloak from DS9 ships that fly insanely close often cant get shot but what do i know? a single ship rammed the thing and it blew up...i think

BTW i want the executor class ship... its cool and i need one to.... get the civilians in line.. bwahahahaha!!!

the borg do not have large numbers of ships. they depend on the strength of their ships, not strength of numbers. which is why 1 cube > a fleet of starships.

want proof? look at wolf 359, the battle in the movie First Contact. The only way the ship in wolf 359 was defeated was by a boarding party, and the only way the ship in the movie was defeated was by Picard hearing the borg collective and hearing where they were weak. At any given time the borg fleet numbers in the low hundreds, including smaller ships, not just cubes. (but not including scout craft).

[Jordanv78]

The main borg ship was a square wasn't it? I mean how lame is that?