Poll: How good am I, considering I've only been playing a year.
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
YOU SUCK
35.00%
7 35.00%
You're kinda good.
30.00%
6 30.00%
50/50
35.00%
7 35.00%
You're hecka good!
0%
0 0%
YOU'RE HELLA GOOD!
0%
0 0%
Total 20 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Me Playing Guitar!
#21
pretty good, better than me.. lol
#22
Being a guitar player myself, and having watched both videos I have a few things to say. First, you can speed pick better than I can. Congrats! Like you, I've never had lessons either.... and speed picking just kind of fails me, i don't really understand it. Though you can do it, you haven't mastered it yet. You're always hitting the wrong string when trying to switch from your g string to your d string.... that drives me absolutely bonkers. Secondly, ANYONE can play drop D power chords like you man.... it's nothing new. I'm not knocking it, you're making good progression I suppose. But it's nothing original, creative, or even difficult to play power chords like that. Thirdly, your rendition of the Sweet child of mine solo bites. You can hit the notes, but you need to put some serious work into your bends. Your bends are ALL off by at least a half step. This looks like something you learned in ten mnutes and just threw online to waste someone's bandwidth. You didnt even play the whole solo! When you got to the more difficult part near the end, you stumbled and the video cut out, whichy leads me to believe you can't really play the whole solo. You have the technique of the solo down, but you lack heart. When I learn to paly something, I learn it because I like it. A solo should have some feeling to it. When you did it, it sounded like a bunch of notes that happened to be in the right key and scale thrown together. No feeling in it, know what I'm saying?

Good progress, keep it up and before long you'll be playing the eruption solo. You know... van halen? Try learning some tapping. It's fun. Also check out Steve Vai, John Petrucci, Joe satriani. You'll like them. I wanted to help, instead of WTFOMG you SUCKZORS! Good work, with another year of practice, you'll be pretty good if you keep working like you have. You're not good yet, but you've got potential. And don't let any of those other guys tell you guitar players are good after 3 or 4 months. They don't know what they're talking about.

P.S. I like your shirt.
#23
aight guys...first of all thank you jedimaster for telling me which forum to post in...second of all thank u ALOT to whoever gave me support...

toiletsupernova, i really cant play the whole solo, in the end wen he starts using the wammy bar, i cant do that, i never experimented too much with the wammy bar and i dont really know how to use it correctly, thats y i just played sumthing different at the end.

also, the first vid i put up, actually i wasnt planning on putting that vid up, ill explain to u guys y that vid sucked so much...it took me like an hour to set up everything for the recording...i had to find the cam, find the cam stand, most of all, the thing that ate up the time was fixing the mic and setting up everything...so after doing various sound tests, i was ready...then i thought that i will record a TEST VIDEO to see everything was rite...and the thing is, that vid i put up IS the test video...bcoz after i got done recording the test vid, i got annoyed and tired and didnt want to record ne thing else...thats y that first vid sucked so much....

also, to "fast pick", its really called tremelo, u have to rest ur wrist on the bridge of the guitar...i really never knew that...wen u rest ur wrist on the bridge, then u pick way way faster! and to tremelo, u just kinda vibrate ur whole hand up and down, u dont rotate ur wrist...

also, wat do u ean my bends r off by a half step? do u mean i need to bend MORE or LESSER than wat i did?

btw dude, dont kid urself, that shirt SUCKS lol...thats the worst shirt i have, but its the first rock band shirt i ever got so i wear it lol...i didnt bother chaning my shirt for the video....

now ive gotten really really ƒucking serious bout playing guitar...now ima try to get lessons, and for now im gonna go online and search stuff...and im gonna push myself to the max and get ATLEAST 3 hours on weekends...yesterday i played i think 4-5 hours...most like 4:30....watch out ppl, ill be ripping b4 u realize it...

and one last point i would like to make that will clear most of this sh!t up........i can play good, but i cant improvise good!!!!!!!!!............that should clear this shit up, bcoz as far as i know, i dont suck, i just suck at improvising, i need to practice more on improvising so it gets better....btw ima make new vids soon, so keep coming to this thread, ill anounce wen theres a new vid!

Additional Comment:
ALSO BTW!!! i wasnt playing drop D u moron, i was playing standard tuning...i tuned my guitar b4 recording....on the GNR solo i did flat tuning to all strings, its how its supposed to be
#24
alright tough guy.... don't call me a moron.... in the first video you weren't playing in drop d? you were jsut using double stops? you DO know what a double stop is right? say you are palying an open e power chord.... you would just play the A and D on the 2nd fret and leave the E out of it. i only watched the video one time... couldnt bear to sit through it again. I gave you constructive criticism.... instead of just telling you straight up that i can paly better turning my guitar over and palying left handed than you on a great day for you.

As for how your bends are off by a half step.... you don't know anything about music theory do you? Some off your bends were sharp, some flat. Can you even READ sheet music? I mean, if you can't its ok, nine out of ten guitar palyers can't. But it's because of dumb shits like you that most respectable musicians think guitarists are retards. Just wanted you to know that. Look up music theory on he internet. Matter of fact, I'll send you some things i used to use when i was less experienced. These will open your eyes a little.

Thank you for the tip on tremelo... i'll have to check it out. Also, AC/DC rules.
#25
btw dude, i didnt mean to call u a moron, i just thought ide throw sumthing rude in, since it is steam room lol...and i dont know wat double stop is lol...and also, i have JUST started to read up on musical theory and its pretty cool....also, i can read tabs, but not ne other kind of musical notes...i know how the musical alphabet goes on guitar but i dont have it memorized on which fret is which note....sorry for callin u a moron man i didnt mean to piss u off...
#26
... I actually just watched it for the first time. I'm not gonna lie. It sucks.
#27
when i heard ur music i went deaf
#28
It's not that bad. It's just the fact that there's no rythm to it all, kinda like you just started picking and put your fingers in random spots and didn't even bother to listen to what you were doing and went with it.
#29
link_4_ever Wrote:now, to stay on topic,
If uve been playing for 1 year, u should be very good. People suck at guitar for the first few months, if u still suck now just quit it...

Yeah you should shut the hell up, really fast.

Music isn't a competition, and even if it was, you wouldn't be a god damned judge. Youtube is down, so alas I can't view your playing. Even if it sucks, it's your expression and it's what YOU want it to be.


That said, you cannot master a guitar in one year. Maybe string together power chords and open chords, play along with slower solos, but getting "very good.."

No, I don't know how you define very good, but I define very good as someone say.. Yngwie Malmsteen, Joe Satriani, Steve Vai, Randy Rhoads, Jimmy Page, Dimebag.

At one year, in all honestly and all that shit, you should be on par with most Linkin Park songs. I've been playing right at 8 years and it still takes me weeks or even months sometimes to learn songs. And by songs, I mean songs with moderate rythms and awesome solos, ala' Domation by Pantera or Dee by Randy Rhoads.

It took me over 3 months to master Dee to a point at which I think I am in the same ballpark as Randy.


Anyway, i'll edit this when the video loads.



edit: Okay seriously you guys are piece of shit haters. Honestly, this kid's been playing a year and he's pretty accurate and quick. For one year, you jam.


Friendly criticism/advice: Learn the concept of keys and how to mesh chords in with scales. That way, when you jump from rythms to leads, it doesn't sound like total pigshit. If you analize a very meshed (meaning, lead and rythm player) player like say.. Zakk Wylde on his DVD 'Boozed, Broozed, and Broken Boned' on which he's constantly alterating from rythm to lead lines, it fits. If he's playing an E or A minor rythm, he always solos in E Minor natural or pentatonic/blues. It fits. I noticed a few times where it fit, and a few times where you just wanted to sound quick and go from chugs to high pitched notes. That's fine, but eventually work a little theory into your playing. I'm not asking you (i'm not asking or telling you anything, just giving you advice that has worked for me) to do anything, but this will help.

Also, it seems you're at about 75% accuracy. Key to sounding great and being more technically accomplished is being 100% accurate. Slow it down, play the licks millions of times until you've pushed it speed wise as far as you want it to go without missing a single note. Accuracy is important. Remember this: (I tried telling Pant/Chris this but I don't think he ever listened) Speed is a biproduct of accuracy. Accuracy is not a biproduct of speed.

Accuracy is essential.

Keep playing and it will come one way or another.
#30
Finally a real guitar player has come up and posted, good job on the advice.
#31
Wow. Awsome advice dude. Can you or some really good guitarist give me their aim/yahoo/msn because I have a few questions...Also, for the millionth time I would like to repeat something: GOD DAMMIT I DON'T SUCK THAT MUCH. THAT VIDEO SUCKED, NOT ME!!! I can play way better than that! Im gonna ƒucking record some songs I really made and show you guys. The FACT: "I don't suck at playing guitar, I just suck at improvising!!!". That said, I would like to repeat one more point I said earlier, and it seems like you guys didn't read my post. That was a test video I made!!! I put it up anyways becuase I was too tired to really make a video, so I just put up the test video!!! OK, now that is done....

Thank ƒuckin' god xDBD actually payed attention to that fact that I've been only playing A YEAR!!! And only recently I've started to get serious about playing. xDBD, since you seem like a pro guitarist, I REALLY REALLY wanna discuss some stuff with you related to guitaring, and this forum isn't the best way to do it, so will you please give me your aim/yahoo/msn?!

Thank god I'm getting some support finally...But I would like to say something to each one of you that voted and posted in this thread: THANK YOU!!! You know why?! Because you guys have opened my eyes, now I know what I really have to do. Now I'm gonna practice like hell. 2 hours at the least. 3 hours at the least on weekends.
#32
learn to pick sweep

you're not a sweet guitar player until you can do so

listen to these guys
www.betweentheburiedandme.com/
#33
GodandRock Wrote:i can read tabs,
lol this made me laugh but ya pretty decent from what i can tell , not bad for 1 year
You said so much without ever parting your lips.

[Image: tap100.jpg]
#34
all i can say is... dude u need ALOT more practice and a new guitar

that barracude isnt gunna cut it

and ur choppy and pick faster than ur fretting hand moves.

anyways guys check out my band Big Grin

http://www.purevolume.com/alcheimcalcentrifuge

Sweep pick rocks
#35
my dog ran crying into the other room and my bird sang to it...(thats bad the bird sings to A. rap B. the vaccume C. jet planes) thats just an indication that well.. YOU SUCK.
#36
ok i just have to start by saying your an idiot. you make a thread asking how good you are at playing guitar based on your video. when ppl say they dont like it, then u deal with it. All you are doing is making excuses every time someone tells you sumthing negative. you did not make this thread to see what other people thought, u made this thread because u think your really good and uve had other ppl tell you that you are good. u made the thread to try to show off. its not working.

now for the rest of you that just say he sucks, shutup. obviously u dont know much about guitar. u cant get great after only 1 year of playing. it takes quite some time to get really good at guitar. theres only been a very small handful of ppl comment on this page that know anything about guitar other then that u strum with one hand and hit frets with the other.

i havent seen your vid yet because im at school, so i cant rate you yet, but either way u shouldnt be worried about how good you are. if your playing music just to impress other people, you are playing for the wrong reason. playing guitar is a way to express your self, make people feel what you are feeling. not to try to look cool or just to get "good". keep playing but change the reason for why you play
#37
Holy hell, you can move your fingers fast.

I didn't really like the tone of this at all, and it was really repetitive. Could you go with a deeper tone and post it?
#38
Lord Sunfire Wrote:not to try to look cool or just to get good
ya cause i know millions who play guitar just so that they can suck at something
You said so much without ever parting your lips.

[Image: tap100.jpg]
#39
_Niko Wrote:all i can say is... dude u need ALOT more practice and a new guitar

that barracude isnt gunna cut it

and ur choppy and pick faster than ur fretting hand moves.

anyways guys check out my band Big Grin

www.purevolume.com/alcheimcalcentrifuge

Sweep pick rocks

... You can't say you have a band and tell people to check you out if you put a ****ing cover up for your page. But you covered Bodom pretty ****ing well. I'd ALMOST say that you actually just put the actual song up and took out the vocals...
#40
What is sweep picking? Is it when you pick precisely and not tremelo? Anyways I liked Lord Sunfire's comments. Some people are saying something that is more meaningfull that others. I might make a new, and better video now that I have time, becuase I have been really busy lately.

Additional Comment:
Also, you guys are forgetting one thing, you are supposed to rate me based on the fact that I've only been playing one year. Most of you guys are forgetting that.


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  guitar lessons for beginner Mushroomhead18nc 1 437 11-09-2009, 03:35 PM
Last Post: D2vengeance
  have a guitar no stereo? link[km] 11 427 11-09-2009, 03:34 PM
Last Post: D2vengeance
  Me Playing Badminton BrioCloud 0 206 05-06-2008, 02:43 PM
Last Post: BrioCloud
  Pot Smoking Teen's Guitar Hero III Sells for $9,100 slashbomb 5 362 02-01-2008, 03:30 PM
Last Post: Screamthoughts
  Guitar Hero 2 Pamela 14 199 07-18-2007, 12:49 AM
Last Post: Pamela
  John Mayer Guitar God The_Avenger 8 431 06-25-2007, 10:13 AM
Last Post: Kyle Destroyer
  Guitar Hero Overated? Mushroomhead18nc 16 384 03-20-2007, 05:24 PM
Last Post: SpoonMan999
  Learning guitar? AngelOfSin 5 205 01-27-2007, 03:15 AM
Last Post: Metalhead Steve
  Uhm... ima be a guitar hero! Bounda 18 366 01-04-2007, 06:00 AM
Last Post: ArrogantlyIgnorant
  Your Guitar Setup: Pics aprreciated Mushroomhead18nc 23 580 12-10-2006, 01:14 AM
Last Post: bigdeath

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)